Plan for Northern Wisconsin Gas Plant Abandoned Amidst Legal Challenges
The Nemadji Trail Energy Center, a proposed $1 billion gas-fired power plant in Superior, Wisconsin, has officially been scrapped. Dairyland Power Cooperative and South Shore Energy, the companies behind the project, have withdrawn their plans, following a series of setbacks and opposition.
In a formal letter to the Public Service Commission (PSC), Daniel McCourtney, Allete’s manager of strategic environmental initiatives, announced the decision to cancel the project. Allete is the parent company of Minnesota Power, which had already distanced itself from the venture last December.
McCourtney noted, “No construction has occurred on NTEC or the (generation tie line). Accordingly, the owners respectfully request that the commission acknowledge their relinquishment of all rights associated with the (approvals).”
Initially approved by the PSC in 2020, the plant was meant to generate between 550 and 625 megawatts of power, offering a reliable energy source as utilities transitioned from coal to renewable energy. However, the project faced strong resistance from Indigenous groups, environmentalists, and local residents, leading to legal battles and permitting delays.
Despite attempts by Clean Wisconsin and the Sierra Club to challenge the PSC’s approval in court, the Wisconsin Supreme Court declined to take up the case. Brett Korte from Clean Wisconsin expressed relief over the cancellation, stating, “All of the folks who have been advocating against this ill-advised power plant can finally breathe a sigh of relief and know that there won’t be a power plant on the banks of the Nemadji River in Superior.”
Complications arose when critical permits expired, as noted by Jennifer Cady of Minnesota Power in a commission filing. The city of Superior also withdrew local approvals, highlighting concerns over environmental impacts and the proximity to a cemetery significant to the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa.
Although the project promised employment opportunities and tax revenue, these benefits were overshadowed by environmental concerns. The decision to cancel comes as utilities in the state face increasing electricity demands, predicted to rise by 40% by 2032 due to growing data center needs.
Meanwhile, state regulators have approved other natural gas projects. Invenergy plans to develop two new plants in southern Wisconsin, and We Energies has received approval for projects in Oak Creek and the town of Paris, with additional plans in Outagamie County. Invenergy also aims to establish plants in Calumet County, which could together generate 1,900 megawatts.



