Originally reported in Courier Texas
Texas voters will address critical decisions on reproductive healthcare on November 3, as they choose between Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) and State Rep. James Talarico (D) for the US Senate.
The candidates hold distinctly opposing views on abortion. Paxton has been a vocal opponent of abortion rights, celebrating the overturning of Roe v. Wade in 2022 and warning medical providers against performing abortions, even in life-threatening cases. In contrast, Talarico condemns what he deems “extreme” abortion restrictions and advocates for reducing Texas’ maternal mortality rates.
Where Do Talarico and Paxton Stand on Texas’ Abortion Ban?
Paxton is a staunch supporter of Texas’ abortion ban. Following the Dobbs decision, which nullified Roe v. Wade, he labeled former federal abortion protections as “unconstitutional and unconscionable.” Paxton has pledged to uphold Texas’ stringent abortion laws, which prohibit the procedure from conception with very few exceptions.
He challenged the Biden administration’s interpretation of the EMTALA law to include emergency abortions, arguing it would turn emergency rooms into makeshift abortion clinics. The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals decided that Texas’ abortion laws override EMTALA, even in emergencies.
Contrarily, Talarico believes that Texas’ abortion laws strip women and healthcare providers of decision-making freedom, a view he holds deeply rooted in his faith. He argues that “pro-life” voters should be concerned about the narrow exceptions in Texas’ abortion ban, which can lead to dire consequences for women in emergency situations.
Dallas resident Lauren Miller shared her harrowing experience. She was forced to travel to Colorado for an abortion necessary to save one of her twins after the other was diagnosed with a fatal condition. “The risk of miscarriage with a Trisomy 18 baby is so severe that I could have lost both babies,” she said in a 2025 interview.
Miller criticized the current political climate, stating, “The decision between Ken Paxton and James Talarico comes down to a simple question: If you believe that a politician should make life or death medical decisions for you and your kids, by all means vote for Ken Paxton. If you believe you and your doctor know your medical needs better than a politician, vote for James Talarico.”
Talarico’s legislative efforts, such as filing HB 819 to repeal pre-Roe v. Wade abortion restrictions, reflect his support for women’s healthcare rights, though the bill did not advance past committee review.
How Would Each Candidate Handle Medical Exceptions to the Ban?
When Amanda Zurawski led a Texas Supreme Court case seeking clarity on medical exceptions to the state’s abortion ban, Paxton opposed the efforts. The court’s refusal to define exceptions was celebrated by Paxton, despite Zurawski’s near-fatal experience due to sepsis.
Zurawski told Courier Texas, “To me, the choice is incredibly obvious. It’s night and day,” praising Talarico for his supportive stance. She fears that Paxton in the Senate could enable widespread restrictions across the country.
Paxton has taken a hard line, as seen in his response to Kate Cox, who, after obtaining judicial permission for an abortion due to a fetal anomaly, faced threats of prosecution from Paxton against her doctor. “He threatened me with 99 years in jail, a $100,000 fine and the loss of my medical license,” said Dr. Damla Karsan.
Talarico advocates for more lenient policies, co-sponsoring SB 31, “The Life of The Mother Act,” which would allow medical professionals to act before a pregnant patient is in mortal danger.
What Would They Do About Texas’ Maternal Mortality Rate?
Texas has a higher maternal mortality rate than the national average, disproportionately affecting women of color. From 2016-2020, Harris County recorded the highest U.S. rate of maternal deaths among Black women.
Talarico has voiced concerns over maternal mortality, endorsing insurance for doulas and midwives and programs like Healthy Start. His campaign aims to address maternal health disparities by expanding programs like WIC and ensuring maternity leave.
Dr. Austin Dennard, a Dallas OB-GYN, criticized Paxton’s approach, which, she claims, allows politicians to interfere in medical judgment. She supports Talarico’s hands-off approach, stating, “OBYNs don’t need politicians practicing medicine from the Capitol. We need them to get out of the exam room and let us do the jobs we sacrificed so much of our lives to learn how to do.”



