With one week left until Election Day and five days of early in-person voting still remaining, North Carolina’s 2024 turnout numbers are telling a striking story — one that raises important questions about how shifts in voting behavior affect both election outcomes and the administration of elections themselves.
As of this writing, nearly 1.6 million North Carolinians have already cast ballots, the vast majority of them in person. That figure dwarfs the 1.16 million votes recorded at the same point during the 2022 midterms — a difference of roughly half a million people. WFAE’s Steve Harrison has been tracking the numbers and says the data carries clear signals for both parties heading into the final stretch.
A Shift Away from Mail Voting — and What It Means
One of the more consequential shifts this cycle is the decline in mail-in voting compared to 2022. Harrison attributes part of this to repeated claims by former President Donald Trump that mail voting is fraudulent — messaging that appears to have moved Republican-leaning voters away from the mail option. While mail ballots have always represented a small share of North Carolina’s overall vote, the practical effect of this shift matters for how elections are run.
When large numbers of voters migrate from mail ballots to early in-person voting in a compressed window, election officials face real logistical pressure: more voters showing up at early voting sites, longer lines, greater demand on poll workers, and increased strain on equipment and facilities. Public trust in elections depends not just on the rules themselves, but on whether the process runs smoothly when voters arrive to exercise their rights. A surge of this scale — half a million additional early votes compared to two years ago — is a significant test of election administration capacity.
It also raises a broader question about how political messaging around voting methods shapes participation. When claims about mail ballot fraud circulate widely, voters change their behavior regardless of whether those claims are verified. Election officials in North Carolina have not reported evidence of widespread mail ballot fraud, yet the behavioral shift is real and measurable in the turnout data.
Who Is Showing Up — and Who Isn’t
The partisan composition of early voters is where the numbers become especially notable. Registered Republicans account for just under 24% of all ballots cast so far — a figure that stands in sharp contrast to both recent midterm cycles. In 2022, a strong year for the GOP nationally, registered Republicans made up 31% of the early vote at this stage. In 2018, a strong year for Democrats, Republicans still held 31% of the early voting pool. This year’s figure represents a meaningful departure from both of those baselines.
In raw terms, registered Democrats have cast nearly twice as many early ballots as registered Republicans. Democrats currently represent just under 42% of the early vote — roughly in line with their shares in 2022 and 2018. The bigger story may be unaffiliated voters, who are turning out at elevated rates compared to prior cycles. State and national polling has shown independent voters leaning toward Democrats this year.
Republican strategist Paul Shumaker addressed this dynamic directly in a recent appearance on Tim Boyum’s Tying it Together podcast, explaining what’s driving unaffiliated voters away from the GOP:
“Here’s what you need to understand with the non-idealogue unaffiliated voter. They do not like Donald Trump right now. A lot of that is not driven by policy. A lot of that is driven by leadership style, OK?”
Republican participation did improve after a slow start. When early voting opened in mid-October, registered Republicans represented less than 20% of ballots cast. That share has climbed since, but whether it can reach 27% — let alone match the 30%-plus figures from 2018 and 2022 — remains an open question with a few days of early voting still ahead.
What the Numbers Mean for Key Races
In the U.S. Senate race, Democrat Roy Cooper holds consistent polling leads of 8 to 10 percentage points over Republican Michael Whatley. Harrison noted that nothing in the early voting data contradicts those polls, making Cooper the clear front-runner.
Down the ballot, the picture is more uncertain. Political observers say Democrats have a realistic — if not guaranteed — shot at flipping the state House, though the state Senate is widely expected to remain in Republican hands. Several Congressional districts currently held by Republicans, including the 11th District in the western mountains and the 1st District along the rural northeast and coast, are also being watched closely.
Shumaker warned that even incumbents in districts considered safely Republican may face unexpected pressure if the partisan composition of Election Day turnout follows the early vote trend:
“If Democrats make up 35% and Republicans make up 27% it’s going to be a bad night for a lot of people.”
He drew a historical parallel to illustrate how quickly assumptions about safe seats can collapse in a wave election:
“A lot of people don’t remember that in 1994 a guy named Tom Foley lost. He was speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives. His district wasn’t on anything.”
Five days of early in-person voting remain before Election Day, and the final composition of the early vote — particularly whether Republican turnout recovers — will be one of the most closely watched indicators of what Tuesday may bring.



