Bay City Calls for State Investigation Into Bridge Toll Company

Drivers crossing two bridges in Bay City, Michigan may not realize it, but a quiet dispute between city officials and a private toll company has been building for months — and it just took a major step forward. The Bay City Commission voted 6-2 Monday to back a letter from Mayor Christopher Girard asking Michigan’s top law enforcement official to take a closer look at how those tolls are being handled.

Girard wrote to Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel requesting a formal investigation into Bay City Bridge Partners, the company that manages toll collection on the Liberty and Independence Bridges. The Bridge Partners are a subsidiary of United Bridge Partners.

At the heart of the mayor’s complaint is how the company has communicated with drivers about unpaid tolls. Girard alleges that some notices sent to motorists “threaten or overstate the company’s ability to prevent motorists from registering or renewing the registration of their vehicles if tolls and associated fees are not paid.” He characterized these communications as “a pressure tactic” to collect payments — a practice he wants the attorney general to scrutinize.

United Bridge Partners CEO Doug Whitt pushed back on that characterization, telling WCMU that unpaid tolls “do not impact a driver’s ability to register their vehicle or renew their registration as United Bridge Partners does not have authority over State of Michigan vehicle fees and requirements.”

Beyond the registration issue, Girard raised a broader set of grievances: excessive late fees, inadequate notice of billing, and a lack of transparency around upcoming price increases. Starting in 2027, the Bridge Partners plan to raise tolls for non-residents by $0.50 and increase pay-by-mail rates by $2.

At Monday’s commission meeting, Girard made clear the complaints aren’t new. “There’s nothing that can be said to this company, unfortunately, that will get their attention,” he said. “I’ve heard enough from motorists, residents, and other folks of these concerns listed and outlined.”

Not all commissioners agreed that escalating to the state was the right move. Commissioner Mark Zanotti cast one of the two dissenting votes, citing the city’s long-term contractual obligations. “We don’t have the money to buy out the contract right now. We don’t even know if they would sell the contract out,” he said. Bay City is locked into a 75-year agreement with the Bridge Partners.

The Company’s Position

Whitt maintained that the company works directly with drivers who have unpaid tolls and has “consistently worked to create an affordable tolling structure.” On the subject of the upcoming rate increase, he noted that “our proposed, and first ever, $0.50 increase is well below the allowable increase amount approved in our agreement with city commission.”

Whitt also pointed to the company’s financial investment in the infrastructure itself, stating the Bridge Partners have put $150 million into bridge upkeep. “Our agreement with Bay City supports the continued long-term investment in these critical bridges,” he said.

This story was reported with contributions from WCMU’s Alvin (AJ) Jones.

Latest News