Nebraska Families Face Legal Hurdles Seeking Compensation for Abuse Cases
The scars left by abuse are evident in Jennifer Martin’s 17-year-old son, who struggles with heightened anxiety and anger after enduring sexual abuse at the state-run Youth Rehabilitation and Treatment Center (YRTC) in Kearney. While the perpetrator is now behind bars, Martin grapples with the state’s accountability, hoping for continued financial support for her son’s therapy, which is currently mandated by the court.
However, Nebraska’s legal landscape presents significant obstacles for families like Martin’s seeking compensation from the state. Legal experts highlight the challenge of suing the state for abuses committed by public employees, as Nebraska law provides considerable protection against such claims.
Attempts to reform these laws have been ongoing, with state senators facing resistance due to concerns over taxpayer costs. In 2024, Governor Jim Pillen vetoed legislation aimed at aiding victims of child abuse in public institutions, citing financial implications.
According to a report by the Inspector General of Nebraska Child Welfare, at least 37 boys have alleged sexual abuse at YRTC-Kearney, a center criticized for fostering a culture that allowed such misconduct. This scandal has reinvigorated legislative efforts for reform as the 2027 session approaches, although the Governor’s Office has not commented on potential support for related bills.
State Sen. Danielle Conrad, a proponent of the previously vetoed bill, questioned the state’s priorities, asking, “If indeed it is such a cost burden upon government entities and taxpayers, how many child abusers and sexual predators are they employing in the first place?”
The root of the issue lies in the doctrine of sovereign immunity, a legal principle that historically protects states from lawsuits. Nebraska law does permit suits for damages caused by public employees, but includes a range of exemptions.
Previously, claims against the state were viable in abuse cases involving state employees, argued former State Sen. Steve Lathrop, until the 2020 Nebraska Supreme Court decision in Moser v. State. This decision upheld state immunity in a negligence lawsuit, emphasizing an exemption for claims “arising out of” assault or battery.
Following this ruling, legislative attempts to address sovereign immunity commenced, but with limited success. Former and current lawmakers, including Lathrop and State Sen. Justin Wayne, have introduced bills to tackle the issue, though none have been enacted.
In 2024, Wayne’s bill, which targeted political subdivisions like school districts, was vetoed by Pillen, who argued it would excessively weaken sovereign immunity and burden taxpayers.
Despite bipartisan criticism of the veto, including from State Sen. Steve Halloran, legislative progress remains stalled. Efforts to advance related bills have faced challenges within the Judiciary Committee, chaired by Sen. Carolyn Bosn, who expressed concerns over the financial impact on public entities.
While Conrad plans to reintroduce legislation in 2027, discussions continue on balancing accountability and fiscal responsibility. Bosn emphasized the need for offender accountability and preventive measures, such as employee background checks and training.
Meanwhile, victims’ families have limited options for seeking state compensation. Federal civil rights cases present a potential avenue, but are resource-intensive. Attorney Maren Chaloupka noted the complexity of pursuing such cases, which can be a lengthy and demanding process.
Other legal routes, including restitution in criminal proceedings or negligence claims against the state, are fraught with difficulties. The recent state Supreme Court case, involving a school district’s alleged negligence in supervising abusive staff, underscores the complexities of pursuing claims under current exemptions.
Ultimately, the debate over Nebraska’s sovereign immunity laws highlights a broader issue of governmental accountability. Without legislative changes, critics argue that the state lacks sufficient motivation to address misconduct swiftly and effectively.
As Conrad stated, “Without strong accountability and oversight measures in place … it perpetuates a culture of abuse and increases the risk and incentive for abuse to continue.”
The Flatwater Free Press is Nebraska’s first independent, nonprofit newsroom focused on investigations and feature stories that matter.
