Controversy and Changes: Watertown School District’s Musical Decision
The Watertown Unified School District once again finds itself in the spotlight after a decision to replace the upcoming spring musical, following a recent history of controversial cultural decisions. This move comes after the district gained attention for banning an instrumental piece associated with LGBTQ+ history earlier this year.
In a recent letter to parents, Interim Superintendent James Feil announced that the high school’s planned production of “Flashdance” would not proceed as the 2027 spring musical. Feil, who stepped into his role on August 1, emphasized that the musical has not been canceled but will be replaced with a different production.
“I have directed that we move forward with a different production,” Feil explained in his letter. He further mentioned that choir teacher Ryan Moldenhauer, who was initially set to direct the play, has chosen not to participate in the new production.
Feil’s decision is rooted in avoiding controversy, drawing from an incident where the Watertown School Board removed “A Mother of A Revolution!” from a spring concert, citing policy violations. “I want to make sure that we are going to accomplish what we are intending to accomplish and to be as inclusive as we can with our community,” Feil stated. He acknowledged the inevitability of differing opinions.
Despite never having seen the 1983 film “Flashdance,” Feil told the Watertown Daily News, “I wasn’t going to start with an X-rated movie. I didn’t take this judgement lightly. I want to mend some fences and build on the quality work that is already here.” The movie tells the story of a young woman aspiring to be a ballerina, rated “R” upon its release.
Following discussions with Moldenhauer and Principal Jason Widiker, Feil explained, “I found no wrongdoing by either of them.” He described the decision as a judgment call, based on his responsibility as interim superintendent.
While some have criticized his decision online, Feil noted that others have expressed gratitude for his choice. Senior student Cannon Jo Wiley, who intended to audition for the lead role in “Flashdance,” expressed disappointment at the cancellation. “When we were told Flashdance was no longer the musical; it was immediate tears for most of us,” Wiley shared.
Wiley, who has worked with Moldenhauer since age eight, added, “Through every show I participate in, I learn so many incredible life lessons.” The loss of Moldenhauer and his team has been particularly disheartening for the students.
Feil cited district policy in his decision-making, emphasizing the importance of administrative review for educational purposes. While Moldenhauer could not be reached for comment, Feil respects his decision to step down from directing the new musical.
Parents like Ian Pilak are seeking clarity on the decision-making process. “I was withholding judgement (when he was hired), but then this is the first major thing that he has done,” Pilak commented, questioning the unilateral decision-making without broader discussion.
A protest is scheduled to take place before the Watertown School Board meeting to support the district’s students and teachers. The district continues to navigate leadership changes, with Feil bringing experience from previous roles in Wisconsin and Michigan.
Feil’s past includes a controversial tenure in Manitowoc, where community members criticized his policies, including a petition demanding his resignation over issues like the provision of free lunches and curriculum changes.
