Northern Wisconsin Nonprofit Ends Big Top Chautauqua Shows After 40 Years

No more shows for Big Top Chautauqua as nonprofit faces financial losses

For four decades, the Lake Superior Big Top Chautauqua has been a beacon of music and culture in northern Wisconsin. However, the curtains are closing on its summer shows, as the nonprofit Ashwabay Alliance has declared an end to its productions due to financial struggles.

Big Top Chautauqua, located in Bayfield, has been a magnet for music lovers, hosting iconic performances by artists like Johnny Cash, Willie Nelson, and Brandi Carlile. Despite its rich history and draw, the nonprofit managing the venue is facing an uncertain future.

Financial Challenges and Legal Scrutiny

On Monday, the Ashwabay Alliance announced it will halt future summer shows, citing inflation, increased costs, and $2.8 million in losses over the past three years. Compounding their troubles, the Wisconsin Department of Justice is investigating whether the alliance misused donor-restricted funds, potentially violating state law.

In 2022, the organization merged with Mt. Ashwabay Ski and Recreation Area, hoping to consolidate resources amidst rising living expenses and doubled insurance premiums. Despite these efforts, ticket sales fell short of expectations by 60% this year.

Scott Griffiths, the alliance’s board president, outlined the financial distress in a letter, noting that reserves built from past fundraising and pandemic relief were depleted. “As you start to hit a spot where your line of credit is maxed out, where the cash reserves are depleted, there just hits a point where you just run out of runway, and that is the situation that we find ourselves in,” he told WPR.

Since 2023, the group has consistently operated at a loss, with a deficit reaching approximately $486,000 that year and about $1.1 million through September of the current year, according to tax filings.

Donor Funds and Board Decisions

Over the years, the alliance relied on the Keepers fund, which had $1 million from over 100 donors, using $480,000 as collateral for a line of credit. Former board member Jim Perry, who resigned following the reallocation of these funds, expressed empathy for the current board’s efforts to rectify past mismanagement.

Legal concerns arose when donor attorneys argued that the board should safeguard these funds per Wisconsin’s Uniform Prudent Management of Institutional Funds Act. The DOJ is reviewing compliance, with the alliance providing requested documents.

The alliance, represented by attorney John Carlson, contends the board imposed fund restrictions. While there’s consideration of dissolving the alliance, Griffiths assured they’d comply with the Attorney General’s decisions.

Looking Forward: Hopes and Challenges

Despite the challenges, some remain optimistic about Big Top’s future. Vincent Osborn, president of the union representing Blue Canvas Orchestra musicians, hopes for a return to the venue’s independent status, allowing community and donor support to rejuvenate it.

Bayfield County Tourism Director Mary Motiff acknowledged the loss but remains hopeful for future solutions, highlighting the increased diversity of local live music venues compared to 40 years ago.

Currently, the alliance has $100,000 to maintain operations until the ski season, threatened by climate conditions. They plan to continue ski hill operations under the Ashwabay Outdoor Educational Foundation and have launched a $250,000 fundraising campaign.

Griffiths emphasized their commitment to fulfilling obligations to staff and creditors, estimating liabilities of at least $1 million. The alliance is reducing its workforce and considering asset sales to navigate these financial waters.

As the organization considers its next steps, Griffiths remains hopeful for new partnerships to shape Big Top’s future. The alliance will host a livestreamed community session to discuss these developments.

Latest News