Three Arizona Judges Voted Out as Chief Justice Calls for Reform of Judicial Elections

Most voters barely glance at the long list of judges on their ballots — and historically, those judges almost always keep their jobs. But Arizona’s 2024 election broke that pattern in a significant way, and the fallout is now prompting serious questions about how the state selects and removes its judges.

For the first time in recent memory, coordinated efforts from both Republican and Democratic groups — along with issue-focused organizations — targeted sitting judges through voter guides and public campaigns. The result: three Arizona judges lost their seats, and the state’s top judicial official is now calling for reform.

Three Judges Voted Out

The judges removed from the bench were Court of Appeals Judge Anni Hill Foster and two Maricopa County Superior Court judges: Judge Michael Rassas and Judge Julie Mata. Their removal came after a wave of voter guides and campaigns circulated by groups on both sides of the political aisle, urging voters to reject certain judges — sometimes with detailed reasoning, sometimes with almost none at all.

Journalist Kiera Riley, reporting for Capitol Media Services, covered the story and explained how the campaigns varied widely in their approach. Some voter guides simply listed judges as “retain” or “reject” without any explanation. Others cited specific rulings, past political affiliations, or campaign donation histories as reasons to vote a judge out.

Election Rulings Put One Judge in the Crosshairs

Judge Anni Hill Foster’s case stands out as particularly notable for voters interested in election administration. Despite being endorsed by the conservative Arizona Free Enterprise Club, she still appeared on Republican voter guides urging her removal — largely due to two rulings tied to election issues in Maricopa County.

The first involved the release of a cast vote record, a large official election document, which Foster declined to release as a public record. The second concerned a legal challenge to election administration practices — including ballot drop boxes and signature verification procedures — which she also rejected. Those two decisions made her a target for groups focused on election-related grievances, even as other conservative organizations stood behind her.

How Arizona’s Judicial Retention System Works

To understand why this matters, it helps to know how Arizona selects its judges in the first place. The state’s appellate courts, the Arizona Supreme Court, and judges in Maricopa, Pima, Pinal, and Coconino counties all use what’s called a retention system. Rather than running in competitive elections, judges are appointed by the governor from a list of candidates screened by independent commissions. They are then periodically placed on the ballot — not against an opponent, but simply as a “yes” or “no” vote by the public.

The intent of this system was to keep judicial selection focused on merit rather than politics. Commissions evaluate judges based on their legal work, experience, and character. A separate body, the Commission on Judicial Performance Review, surveys attorneys and others who have appeared before each judge to assess how well they’re performing on the bench.

This largely quiet corner of the ballot remained that way until around 2022, when organized efforts to inform — and mobilize — voters about judicial retention races began gaining traction from multiple directions.

Arizona’s Chief Justice Sounds the Alarm

Arizona Supreme Court Chief Justice Ann Scott Timmer has not been quiet about her reaction. She told Riley she was deeply concerned — and frankly angry — about losing three qualified judges who had gone through every step of the rigorous appointment process.

Her bigger worry, though, is what comes next. If sitting on the bench means becoming the target of partisan campaigns and having your name tied to negative content that lives on the internet long after Election Day, talented legal professionals may simply decide the job isn’t worth it. Riley reported that Timmer said she has already heard from judges who regret taking their positions on the bench.

As Riley summarized Timmer’s concern: being a judge is already a difficult job — there’s always a losing party walking out of a courtroom — and that inherent controversy is now being amplified by politically motivated campaigns.

Voters Still Have a Legitimate Role

Even so, the retention system exists precisely because voters deserve a voice in who holds judicial power. Citizens have every right to research how judges have ruled and whether those decisions reflect their values and expectations of the courts. Voter engagement in judicial races — when it’s informed — is a healthy part of democratic accountability.

The tension Chief Justice Timmer is grappling with is a real one: how do you protect judicial independence and attract qualified candidates while also preserving the public’s legitimate ability to remove judges they believe are failing in their duties?

What Reforms Are Being Considered

Timmer is already thinking ahead to 2028, and early ideas for reform are beginning to surface. According to Riley’s reporting, possibilities include extending judges’ term lengths, raising the threshold of “no” votes required to remove a judge, and revisiting how judges are evaluated and graded before they appear on the ballot.

None of these proposals are finalized, but the conversation is underway. Arizona’s Citizens Clean Elections Commission is also already looking ahead to 2028, with an eye toward better informing voters about down-ballot races — including judicial retention contests — well before they reach the voting booth.

Meanwhile, related legal proceedings continue to shape Arizona’s political landscape. The Arizona Court of Appeals is preparing to hear arguments in the state’s “fake electors” case, and Arizona Democrats are reshaping legislative committee structures as they prepare to control both chambers of the state legislature for the first time in over 60 years. The broader question of how Arizona’s institutions — judicial and legislative — adapt to a more politically charged environment will be one to watch closely in the years ahead.

Latest News