Candidates Criticize Evers, GOP After $1.8B Tax Deal Fails in Legislature

Three people sit on stage, two listening while the person in the center speaks into a microphone during a panel discussion.

The aftermath of a failed $1.8 billion tax cut and school funding proposal left Wisconsin’s political landscape buzzing with criticism directed at Gov. Tony Evers and Republican leaders. Key figures in the race for governor did not hold back their opinions on how the negotiations were managed.

Failed Legislative Deal Sparks Political Criticism

The proposed measure aimed to allocate a significant portion of the state’s surplus towards tax rebate checks, property tax relief, and special education funding. Announced by Governor Evers, along with Republican Assembly Speaker Robin Vos and Senate Majority Leader Devin LeMahieu, the deal quickly became a focal point of contention among gubernatorial candidates.

Republican U.S. Rep. Tom Tiffany expressed disapproval, arguing that the tax cuts fell short. Meanwhile, a diverse group of Democratic hopefuls, including Lt. Gov. Sara Rodriguez, state Rep. Francesca Hong, Sen. Kelda Roys, former Lt. Gov. Mandela Barnes, former Department of Administration Secretary Joel Brennan, and Milwaukee County Executive David Crowley, also voiced opposition, emphasizing the Republican majority’s influence in the state legislature.

Diverse Reactions from Democratic Leaders

Missy Hughes, former Director of the Wisconsin Economic Development Corporation, stood apart by supporting the compromise. However, despite bipartisan backing in the Assembly, the proposal failed in the Senate with unanimous Democratic opposition and three Republican dissenters.

Following the Senate’s decision, Rep. Francesca Hong took to social media to assert that Wisconsin lawmakers rejected “election-year gimmicks” that posed risks to long-term stability. She pledged to address structural issues in schools and communities through “smart and intentional investment.”

Former Lt. Gov. Mandela Barnes acknowledged the bill’s potential benefits for schools but criticized it for not addressing systemic failures, advocating for a Democratic trifecta to achieve the “Wisconsin way” of governance.

Calls for Collaborative Governance

In an interview with WPR, David Crowley highlighted the need for collaboration in budget negotiations, noting the adverse impact on Wisconsin residents due to the bill’s failure. He emphasized that decisions should prioritize public welfare over political power dynamics.

Lt. Gov. Sara Rodriguez, in a conversation with WISN-TV, expressed aspirations for Democratic control of the legislature and the governor’s office, aiming to fulfill the desires of Wisconsinites.

Missy Hughes, in a video post on social media, criticized both Republican and Democratic candidates for prioritizing electoral ambitions over the interests of struggling Wisconsinites, lamenting the lost opportunity for substantial education funding.

former WEDC Director Missy Hughes, center, speaks during a governor candidate forum while sitting next to Sen. Kelda Roys, left, and former DOA Secretary Joel Brennan, right, on Wednesday, Jan. 21, 2026, at the Cooperage in Milwaukee, Wis. Angela Major/WPR

Republican Perspectives and Future Plans

Former Madison Rep. Brett Hulsey, who supported the measure, expressed his stance on social media, implying alignment with Wisconsinites’ interests. Rep. Tiffany, echoing his critique, outlined plans to return the budget surplus to taxpayers and repeal a controversial partial state budget veto by Evers.

Insights from WisPolitics revealed that a Republican senator received calls from Tiffany expressing concerns about the spending bill, which was echoed by Evers’ spokesperson Britt Cudaback. Cudaback clarified that Republican support hinged on the inclusion of tax rebate checks.

Contrary to these claims, a post by the chief of staff for Sen. Van Wanggaard contested the existence of such assurances from the Senate GOP, adding another layer to the complex dynamics of Wisconsin’s political arena.

Latest News