In a bold move to embrace its storied history while planning for the future, Otto Bookstore is set to double its space by expanding into an adjacent property. This marks the first expansion for the bookstore, a mainstay in Williamsport for over 180 years.
Owner Katy Nassberg shared her excitement, stating, “We have been looking to…either expand or move. When this came, it was the perfect opportunity, because we were really looking to expand our space.” The expansion will occupy part of the former Amber Rose Bridal Shop, conveniently located next to their current West Fourth Street location.
John Shableski, the bookstore’s General Manager, expressed enthusiasm over the deal offered by the bridal shop’s property owners, calling it an offer they “couldn’t refuse.” The plan involves completing the build-out within 60 days, which includes creating a doorway to merge the two spaces seamlessly.
The newly acquired space will feature a diverse selection of fiction and non-fiction bestsellers aimed at both young and mature readers, while the existing area will continue to serve as a hub for children’s literature. Shableski adds a whimsical touch to the expansion, mentioning, “And we’ve got a couple of dragons we’re putting in there.”
A Storied History in Williamsport
With roots dating back to 1841, Otto Bookstore began as A.D. Lundy and Co., a store that eventually found its niche in bookselling. Originally, books were just one part of their inventory, but over time, under John Otto’s leadership, the store evolved into a dedicated bookstore.
Now managed by Katy Nassberg and her husband Isak Sidenbladh, Otto Bookstore is committed to maintaining its presence in downtown Williamsport, a place Nassberg cherishes deeply. “I take very seriously the fact that the Otto Bookstore has been in the heart of downtown Williamsport for well over a century,” she said.
Expansion a sign of stability, growth in independent bookstore sales
Having navigated challenges like the rise of e-books and the pandemic, independent bookstores are experiencing a resurgence. Shableski, who has over 25 years in the industry, believes the tactile experiences offered by local stores are drawing people back.
According to Shableski, Otto Bookstore experienced its best sales year in 2025 since 2015, and he is optimistic about surpassing pre-Amazon sales figures. “To be a part of that is really pretty awesome,” he said, expressing the significance of being involved with a legacy bookstore.
