As the role of generative artificial intelligence in education expands, concerns about its impact on young learners are growing. A comprehensive study by the Brookings Institution’s Center for Universal Education reveals that the potential downsides currently outweigh the benefits.
The study gathered insights from students, parents, educators, and tech specialists across 50 countries, alongside a review of extensive academic literature. It highlights how AI could potentially disrupt children’s foundational development, though it also suggests that these challenges are not beyond repair.
Pros and Cons of AI in Education
Pro: Enhancing Reading and Writing Skills
According to educators, AI can be particularly beneficial for language learning, adapting text complexity to suit individual student levels and providing a private space for practice. AI tools have been noted to assist in overcoming writer’s block and improving the organization, syntax, and grammar in students’ writing.
Con: Impeding Cognitive Development
The Brookings report cautions against AI’s potential to negatively affect cognitive growth, as students may increasingly rely on AI for answers, thereby diminishing their problem-solving skills. Rebecca Winthrop of Brookings emphasizes, “When kids use generative AI that tells them what the answer is … they are not thinking for themselves.”
Pro: Streamlining Teachers’ Workloads
The report notes AI’s ability to automate tasks like generating emails, translating materials, and creating educational resources, potentially saving teachers significant time. Some studies suggest this could amount to nearly six hours saved per week.
Pro/Con: Equity and Inequity Dilemmas
AI’s capacity to reach students excluded from traditional education is significant, as seen in Afghanistan where AI helps deliver curriculum content to girls who face educational barriers. However, the disparity in AI tool quality between wealthy and underfunded schools raises equity concerns, as more advanced models are often more accurate but less accessible to less affluent communities.
Con: Affecting Social and Emotional Skills
The study points out the risk AI poses to students’ social and emotional development, with chatbots potentially reinforcing users’ beliefs and limiting exposure to diverse perspectives. Winthrop illustrates this with a chatbot example that validates a child’s complaints about chores, unlike a peer who might challenge their viewpoint.
Recommendations for a Balanced Approach
The Brookings report suggests several strategies to mitigate AI’s risks while leveraging its benefits:
- Shift educational focus from rote tasks to fostering curiosity and critical thinking.
- Design AI to challenge preconceived notions rather than affirm them.
- Encourage collaborations between educators and tech developers to create effective educational AI tools.
- Implement comprehensive AI literacy programs for students and teachers.
- Ensure equitable AI access to prevent further educational disparity.
- Regulate AI in education to safeguard students’ cognitive and emotional well-being.
This proactive “premortem” approach by Brookings aims to address AI’s emerging challenges in education before they escalate, emphasizing the urgency and feasibility of taking corrective action now.
Copyright 2026 NPR
